Thursday, September 04, 2008

BMW: Being rich a bane for Sanjeev Nanda


Is Sanjeev Nanda paying for the crime of drunken driving committed nine years ago on a foggy Delhi winter morning or is he being punished for being rich, driving a BMW and first trying to buy forgiveness and then the entire justice system? The collective middle class conscience may say he is being served his just desserts but for those who know him, it is simple a case of really bad luck.
Grandson of former Naval chief Admiral SM Nanda, Sanjeev is one of the two children born to Suresh Nanda. The fact that he was born with a silver spoon became his nemesis as he became the target of the media.
A regular Delhi lad, Sanjeev studied at the Modern School and then moved to University of Pennsylvania to do his graduation. He shifted to Paris to do his masters in Business Management at Insead, one of the world's leading graduate business schools.
Unfortunately he couldn't complete the course as just days before returning to his university, Sanjeev and his friends met with the accident.
The German automaker must thank him as BMW, after this accident, became a household name in India. In 1999, only a select few could buy a BMW. The fact that a rich kid was driving it made it all the more a high profile case. Had he been driving a Maruti or an Ambassador car, he would have just got a passing reference in the list of road accidents. As the case progressed, Nanda become synonymous with the Bollywood rich kid image of being a spoilt brat, partying all night and drinking while driving.
Up close, his friends paint a different picture altogether. People who know him, just can't believe it. "He is such a well-behaved, soft spoken boy and a perfect gentleman. What has happened to him is too harsh. In hindsight, it seems, that since the accident, he has changed. He quit drinking after the accident and in all the parties that he attends, he kept to himself and always maintained a low profile," says a close friend on conditions of anonymity.
Sanjeev was first arrested in January 10, 1999 and he spent nine months in Tihar Jail. Obviously he couldn't complete his MBA from Insead, but that did not make him bitter. During his nine-month stay in jail, Sanjeev acted the good Samaritan and volunteered to teach computers to inmates. By the time he got bail, he was labeled the 'Computer Master' at Tihar.
The nine-year-long case took its toll on Sanjeev. He lost the youthfulness of a 20-year-old. Although the Nandas paid hefty compensations to the victims, his "rich-kid and spoilt-brat" image made him a villain. For nine years, he tried hard to shake off his identity as Sanjeev Nanda, the BMW guy.
According to his family members, "Sanjeev became recluse because every time people addressed him as a 'BMW' guy, he felt he was being punished. The conviction may have come today, but Sanjeev Nanda has been punished everyday for nine years. If you see his images in the year of the accident – you will see a Sanjeev with a full head of hair. Nine years later, he has lost it all."
Being rich, a bane
Coming from an affluent family, the Nandas tried all the machinations and intrigues to win the case. However, it proved futile as the rich and the mighty in this country cannot be set free. Sanjeev 's affluence and the imported car that he was driving turned out to be his nemesis. Whoever has met Sanjeev, believes that he has been punished more than enough. He was in Tihar for nine months and after that for nine years the case hung over his head as a sword, prohibiting him from leading a normal life.

14 comments:

shilpi sud said...

Excellent opinion, i totally agree with you, Sanjeev Nanda's affluent status was indeed a bane. The BMW accident could have happened with anyone, but just because the culprits were high-profile businessman the case became a household discussion. After reading this i feel, Sanjeev Nanda is not really a bad man but just a victim of bad luck.

Ankur wadhwa said...

Computer master at tihar that's interesting, if he really was a brat, rich spoilt kid, why would he do it. The compensations to the families cannot compensate for the lives lost but it was just misfortune. Im from delhi, i have been hearing about such cases all my life but none have got such prominence as the BMW case.

Yusuf Khan said...

Being rich a bane indeed. BMW hit-and run case is a case of negligent and rash driving that we all do sometimes. I ve got a friend who accidently while reversing hit a scooter and the guy driving his arm does that mean he is guilty of culpable homicide? IT WAS ACCIDENT, he cant be punished for it throughout his life. Ofcourse he made a mistake and should be punished for it but that punishment should not be a burden for life, coz he is not a criminal but a man caught in the web of bad luck.

Kumar Akshay said...

A wharton graduate, a respected businessman, INSEAD student...i dont believe he had such a fate. He could have brought laurels for India in the hospitality industry where we seriously lack. Its strange how just a moment of bad luck can change the life of a man forever.

Simran Ahuja said...

Hmm..Sanjeev Nanda must be paying back for some bad karma in his previous life. I sympathise with him, it was indeed his bad luck that got him involved in such an incident.

Manisha Aggarwal said...

Why does a person have to bear the burden of guilt even after being punished for his mistakes. Our Judicial System has the provision of reducing the sentence of even the most harcore criminals if they see an improvement in him, here Sanjeev Nanda's 5 year sentence was reduced because of his good samaritan behaviour, then why do people think the court has been lenient on him?

Vishal Sharma said...

Sanjeev Nanda was 19 years old and a student of B school in the US, he was in Delhi for vacation when this infamous BMW hit and run accident happened. After the accident he was arrested and spent nine months in jail plus 9 years of sword hanging on the head..If that is not enough he became a known name all over India and was tagged the killer BMW guy...Sanjeev Nanda have been punished enough, it's time we all move on.

Megha Pandey said...

I agree with the author of this blog post that Sanjeev Nanda is guilty of committing unintentional mistake which took lives of 6 people and has been punished enough for it already. A person cannot be punished throughout his life for doing something wrong 10 years ago. He deserved a punishment which he got, now he deserves a life, which he should get. I think more than jail punishment, its the lifetime tag of being that "BMW Guy" that will hurt Sanjeev Nanda forever. No one deserves a punishment for life, he should now be left to live in peace.

Krishna Pandit said...

Y r u guys supporting a killer who killed 6 innocent people. Of course it was an accident but had he been not drunk this would have never happened. He was sentenced for 5 years which was appropriate for his crimes. However, his sentence was reduced to two years, which is not right.

Vishal Sharma said...

@ krishna...dude i'm not supporting Sanjeev Nanda, i know he is at fault and because of him 6 people lost their lives..but what i'm saying is it was an accident and he shouldn't be treated as a killer. His sentence was reduced for his good behaviour and not because he is a rich guy who paid the authorities to set him free. He has got his share of punishments is all i'm saying.

Shilpi Sud said...

Sanjeev Nanda with a dream to turn businesses into empires, embarked into the world of entrepreneurship; and as professionals were put together to manage the show, Nanda stepped in to play the role of 'managing the managers' while focusing equally on business development. A Businessman with a vision, Nanda has been successful in every venture he has stepped into.
“Challenges are a process of learning. The idea is not to bow down and give up, but take them as a cue to work harder to achieve the goals one has set for himself. I try to ensure that I do not get distracted, but stay committed to my dream of making my businesses the best in the country" said Sanjeev Nanda once philosophically about his life. Life has not been a cakewalk for Sanjeev Nanda but with the kind of dynamism he has, he is sure to make it big.

Peep into the lives of successful and famous and one will find phases of darkness or suffering. These phases often leave their mark in the form of invaluable learning’s, as painful times help in surfacing the best of person’s values and virtues.

Owing to the hue and cry created by Media, Sanjeev’s name on the internet invariably pops up the infamous BMW hit-and-run case. What very few are able to see is that he has suffered enough for his unintentional mistake, that he compensated the victims to their satisfaction and faced the trial in the hope of justice. It was only in 2009, 10 years after the unfortunate incident, that Justice Kailash Gambhir reduced Nanda's sentence after terming it a case of negligence rather than culpable homicide. Whoever has met Sanjeev, believes that he has been punished more than enough.

Sanjeev Nanda, who graduated from The Wharton School, one of the finest business schools in the US, has the calibre and vigour to put the past as past and look ahead to opportunities and blessings that life has to offer. Media hue and cry will always be there, but for the people who know Sanjeev Nanda well and have worked with him, he will always be an exemplary businessman, a great friend & family man and above all a good human being.

Anonymous said...

He was DRUNK and SPEEDING and KILLED 6 innocent people. MEGHA PANDEY - The 'accident' was caused by his recklessness. There was a lot of bribery and corruption going on from his side.

Being rich a bane... would you rather live in poverty???

Anonymous said...

i saw this articles

Reality Check said...

Tell that to the kids of the 6 policemen whom he killed.

Why did he try to hide from his mistake. He deserves every second of what happened to him